No Body, No Mind: Why Consciousness Cannot Float Free of Flesh
There is a persistent fantasy in the history of thinking about intelligence: that mind is essentially weightless. That it is a pure process — reasoning, pattern recognition, information integration — that could, in principle, run on any substrate, in any form, detached from the particular physical circumstances of its operation. The history of cognitive science and artificial intelligence is partly the history of this fantasy, and of its repeated failure. The failure is not technical. It is conceptual. Mind, on the best available evidence from neuroscience , phenomenology , and biology, is not something that happens to be housed in a body. It is something a body does. Consciousness — understood as the combination of inner experience and reflection on that experience — is rooted, at its origin, in a vulnerable, metabolically regulated organism that depends on its environment to survive, that can be harmed, that is always at some level at risk. This is not a romantic claim about the s...