Victims and Predators in Medicine: Roles, Not Identities
In any medical encounter, two dynamics are always present: an asymmetry of power , and the constant risk of what that asymmetry can become. We rarely speak plainly about this. But if we want to understand why so many clinical relationships go wrong — not dramatically, not with malice, but quietly and structurally — we need to look honestly at the positions people slide into under pressure. The words "victim" and "predator" carry heavy moral weight. Used carelessly, they assign permanent identities: the evil doctor, the helpless patient, the corrupt institution. That is not what these words mean here. A predatory position is one in which a person uses power, knowledge, or institutional backing in ways that disregard someone else's dignity. A victim position is one centered on helplessness — on being acted upon, on having no agency, on being owed rather than responsible. Both are positions people move through. Neither is a fixed character trait. How the Slide H...